Is 'but rather' considered grammatically correct? - English ...

In: In Latin, when a group of males and females is combined, the neutral plural form is not used, but rather the masculine is. 'but rather' is perfectly ... EnglishLanguage&UsageStackExchangeisaquestionandanswersiteforlinguists,etymologists,andseriousEnglishlanguageenthusiasts.Itonlytakesaminutetosignup. Signuptojointhiscommunity Anybodycanaskaquestion Anybodycananswer Thebestanswersarevotedupandrisetothetop Home Public Questions Tags Users Unanswered Teams StackOverflowforTeams –Collaborateandshareknowledgewithaprivategroup. CreateafreeTeam WhatisTeams? Teams CreatefreeTeam Teams Q&Aforwork Connectandshareknowledgewithinasinglelocationthatisstructuredandeasytosearch. Learnmore Is'butrather'consideredgrammaticallycorrect? AskQuestion Asked 9years,7monthsago Active 11monthsago Viewed 197ktimes 13 8 IsthiscommentthatImadeheregrammaticallycorrect? InLatin,whenagroupofmalesandfemalesiscombined,theneutralpluralformisnotused,butratherthemasculineis. grammaticalityadverbsconjunctions Share Improvethisquestion Follow editedJan20at0:22 JEL 31.8k44goldbadges6363silverbadges104104bronzebadges askedMay16'12at16:16 AdamMoshehAdamMosheh 49511goldbadge66silverbadges1616bronzebadges 4 2 Pleaseincludethecommentinthequestiontopreventlinkrot. – MonicaCellio May16'12at16:25 Justcopythecommenthereandaskamorespecificgrammaticalquestion?Whatexactlyisyourconcern?Isittheellipsis? – Mitch May16'12at16:27 The"butrather"constructisalittleconfusingtome. – AdamMosheh May16'12at16:36 Doyoumean,like,intoonegiantperson?Orintoavatofstew?Ordoyoumean,"whenagroupofmalesandagroupoffemalesarecombined...?" – D.Patrick May16'12at16:48 Addacomment  |  3Answers 3 Active Oldest Votes 16 In: InLatin,whenagroupofmalesandfemalesiscombined,theneutralpluralformisnotused,butratherthemasculineis. 'butrather'isperfectlyfineandagoodalternativeto: InLatin,whenagroupofmalesandfemalesiscombined,theneutralpluralformisnotused;ratherthemasculineis. 'Rather'islike'instead';using'but'allowsitinoneconjoinedsentenceratherthanaseparateone. Share Improvethisanswer Follow answeredMay16'12at17:44 MitchMitch 67.8k2525goldbadges131131silverbadges253253bronzebadges 0 Addacomment  |  3 Assumingyouarereferringtotheclause"whenagroupofmalesandfemalesiscombined"thentheansweris"Yes,itiscorrect."Becauseyouaretalkingaboutagroup(singular),theverbshouldbeis.Wereyoutorestateit:"whenmalesandfemalesiscombined"itwould,ofcoursebewrong,andshouldbewritten:"whenmalesandfemalesarecombined"becauseyouareusingapluralsubject. Share Improvethisanswer Follow answeredMay16'12at16:25 treeheadtreehead 28311silverbadge55bronzebadges Addacomment  |  2 Inresponsetowhattreeheadasserted,theverb"combined"shouldbenotedtobeofgreatimportancewhenrevisingthestatement"InLatin,whenagroupofmalesandfemalesiscombined,theneutralpluralformisnotused,butratherthemasculineis."Theword"combined"isusedtoshowthatthereare2ormorethingswhicharebeingbroughttogethertocreate1.Therefore,itwouldnotbecorrecttosaythatagroup(thealreadycombinedform)oftwocomponents(malesandfemales)iscombined.However,if"whenagroupofmalesandfemalesiscombined"ismeanttoreferto'agroupofmales'and'agroupoffemales'beingcombined,thepluralform'are'shouldbeusedinsteadofthesingularform'is'duetotheexistenceoftherebeing2things.Anobjectcannotcombinewithitselfunlessitweretodisintegratebeforehand. Share Improvethisanswer Follow answeredJan20'14at1:50 AlexanderAlexander 2111bronzebadge Addacomment  |  Highlyactivequestion.Earn10reputation(notcountingtheassociationbonus)inordertoanswerthisquestion.Thereputationrequirementhelpsprotectthisquestionfromspamandnon-answeractivity. Nottheansweryou'relookingfor?Browseotherquestionstaggedgrammaticalityadverbsconjunctionsoraskyourownquestion. TheOverflowBlog MillineryontheStack:JoinusforWinter(Summer?)Bash,2021! Congratulationsareinorder!Thesesitesareleavingbeta FeaturedonMeta ProvidingaJavaScriptAPIforuserscripts Congratulationstothe59sitesthatjustleftBeta Linked 8 Is"butrather"grammaticallycorrect? 19 EtceteravsEtal Related 0 YouandMeboth 2 WhyIs"Youdidwell."EvenGrammaticallyCorrect(AmericanEnglish)? 1 "Butfrom"or"Butratherfrom"? 3 Isthephrase"variousinformation"grammaticallycorrect? 0 Isthisrelativeclausegrammaticallycorrect? HotNetworkQuestions Doesthereexistanautomorphismofafinitelygeneratedgroupwithperiodicpointsofunboundedperiod? WherecanyouplayagainstAlphaZero? Hidingsuperstrengthinplainsightatthegym Can'tsolvewithNDSolveasimplecircuitwithalosslesstransmissionline(awaveequation) FittingsinewavewithlminRforcircadianactivity-frequencies? Candeeppreparationfortheearlynoveltybeuseful? Couldproducingagravebugthatmadeheadlinesmakeyouunemployable? Windows11tryingtosneakontoWindows10system? DoesthistweaktoJumpingruleshaveanypitfallsorproblematicinteractions? Whycasteranglecauseswheelstoself-center? Are'FunctionalIndexes'SupportedinMSSQLServer? HowcanIstopmyselffromprintingmyterminal Renegotiatingastartdateonrequestofcurrentemployer(aftercontractsigned)? DidINIfilesworkinadifferentwayonWindows3.xthantoday? Variablenumberofarguments:generatealignmentcharacters Isthis"Bait-And-Switch"defencepossible? Howtoplayalowwisdomcharacterwiththeseflawsandideals? Wrongfullyaccusedoflendingmysecuritybadgetoanotheremployee WhydoesVoldemortholdhiswandinthismanner? WherecanIfindthedatasheetofLT706? WhataretheboxesaroundtheairportontheIVAOApproach(APP)screen? Whydon'tsimplemachineschangetheamountofenergyneeded? PSEAdventCalendar2021(Day17):That'sthewaythecookiecrumbles Whataresatellitetime,GPStime,andUTCtime? morehotquestions Questionfeed SubscribetoRSS Questionfeed TosubscribetothisRSSfeed,copyandpastethisURLintoyourRSSreader. Yourprivacy Byclicking“Acceptallcookies”,youagreeStackExchangecanstorecookiesonyourdeviceanddiscloseinformationinaccordancewithourCookiePolicy. Acceptallcookies Customizesettings