[新聞] 陽台飄來二手菸...孕婦告鄰判賠萬元- Gossiping

文章推薦指數： 80 %
投票人數：10人

可詳看版規 台北市李姓孕婦因鄰居二手菸從陽台飄進住處，拍下影片提告侵害健康權和居住安寧， ... (臺灣) ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Gossiping/M.1573443711. 熱門文章 看板查詢 看板 Gossiping 標題 [新聞]陽台飄來二手菸...孕婦告鄰判賠萬元 作者 medi588 時間 MonNov1111:41:452019 人氣 推:410 噓:28 留言:636 更多medi588文章 相同討論串 返回Gossiping看板 首頁 Gossiping [新聞]陽台飄來二手菸...孕婦告鄰判賠萬元 分享給朋友 ※發文無1~6小標格式或未依順序任意刪除者會被刪文 1.媒體來源:UDN ※例如蘋果日報、自由時報（請參考版規下方的核准媒體名單） 2.記者署名聯合報記者蕭雅娟／台北報導 ※沒有在這打上記者署名的新聞會被水桶14天編輯非記者 ※外電至少要有來源或編輯如:法新社 3.完整新聞標題:陽台飄來二手菸...孕婦告鄰判賠萬元 ※標題沒有完整寫出來--->依照板規刪除文章 4.完整新聞內文: ※社論特稿都不能貼！違者刪除（政治類水桶3個月)，貼廣告也會被刪除喔！可詳看版規 台北市李姓孕婦因鄰居二手菸從陽台飄進住處，拍下影片提告侵害健康權和居住安寧，求 償十萬元。

士林地方法院認為，二手菸確實飄進住家，且超過孕婦容忍範圍，判李婦鄰居 賠償一萬元精神慰撫金。

李婦認為同住五樓鄰居男子長期在自家陽台抽菸，二手菸穿過陽台飄進住家，嚴重影響懷 有身孕的她，多次投訴社區管委會仍未改善，主張二手菸嚴重影響健康權及居住安寧，訴 請抽菸的鄰居賠償十萬元精神慰撫金。

退休的男子反駁，李婦沒舉證二手菸造成的實際損害，二手菸縱使飄入住處，也非侵害居 住安寧，不得請求損害賠償。

法官勘驗李婦從陽台拍攝鄰居抽菸六段影片，兩戶房屋陽台下方有玻璃帷幕區隔，上方則 是格柵區隔，距離相當近，男子坐在玻璃帷幕旁抽菸、陽台上有菸灰缸，現場菸霧飄散， 認定二手菸飄散至李婦住處。

衛福部國民健康署網站資料顯示，二手菸是被動或非自願吸入的環境菸煙，聯合國世界衛 生組織列為頭號致癌物質。

李婦的孕婦健康手冊證明當時已懷孕七個月，二手菸影響健康 。

法官認定，男子抽菸所生二手菸侵入李婦房屋，超過一般人能容忍範圍，侵害居住安寧， 且男子聲稱家裡有三名未滿七歲子女才不在住處內抽菸，顯然知道二手菸對人體的危害才 到陽台抽菸。

法官認為，從住處製造噪音、喧囂、振動及排放煙氣等方式侵害他人居住安寧，逾一般人 所能容忍範圍，情節重大者，得請求賠償精神慰撫金，本案二手菸也適用。

衡酌兩人經濟 狀況及二手菸危害情形，判男子賠償一萬元，可上訴。

5.完整新聞連結(或短網址):https://udn.com/news/story/11315/4156921 ※當新聞連結過長時，需提供短網址方便網友點擊 6.備註: ※一個人一天只能張貼一則新聞，被刪或自刪也算額度內，超貼者水桶，請注意 這樣的時間成本跟人事成本，一萬塊元是划算的嗎? -- https://imgur.com/a/EP2pEHd 醒了我醒了 -- ※發信站:批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc),來自:101.9.211.47(臺灣) ※文章網址:https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/Gossiping/M.1573443711.A.5E8.html →littlegreen:讚1.165.110.611/1111:42 推easyfish:爽218.164.114.3611/1111:42 推kingtama:讚59.124.228.8211/1111:42 →kingtama:划算59.124.228.8211/1111:43 推clavi:吸菸的都吃屎好嗎118.232.195.18511/1111:43 推a0913:就一個教訓一堆人都不想燻自己臭死別人218.210.62.411/1111:43 推drunknmunky:可以讓賤人不抽無價223.138.209.6311/1111:43 推oneloveone:讚39.13.36.16011/1111:43 推kutkin:才100包菸42.73.49.22611/1111:43 推qsccft123:抽菸都是垃圾人渣114.136.45.2711/1111:43 推e34l892:你要抽就抽但不要飄來我這啊180.217.161.5711/1111:43 →a0913:而且有判例後這人再犯會加重處罰218.210.62.411/1111:43 推Meerz:爽223.141.122.2011/1111:43 推YMSH205:溫馨111.71.89.18111/1111:43 推whiteseyes:才一萬?孕婦吸到二手菸很不好耶125.231.221.22811/1111:44 →a0913:所以從此他只能下去大廳外抽菸了218.210.62.411/1111:44 推Yusei0516:不虧27.52.101.8511/1111:44 →garman0403:太少了吧111.71.66.3911/1111:44 推zu00405479:幹，遇到有人跑到家樓下抽菸的怎麼解?211.21.202.23511/1111:44 →LoveMakeLove:下去吸180.217.107.20411/1111:45 推chocoball:1萬太少應該罰10倍吸煙的都垃圾1.200.40.25211/1111:45 推coolrgin:垃圾袋套頭再抽煙111.243.145.3811/1111:45 →whiteseyes:起碼要100萬吧胎兒有生命危險耶125.231.221.22811/1111:45 推aidaP:太少惹。

影響別人真噁101.10.83.16011/1111:45 噓uieasier:自己都有小孩了還不戒煙1.163.179.23311/1111:45 推IHD:這時候自助餐要挺誰呢?吸二手煙的自由?114.43.155.4911/1111:46 →lazycat5:房間抽啊，該學學天龍人，菸氣不外漏49.216.46.11511/1111:46 推dearwilliam:樓下抽菸，我會去洗窗戶220.133.153.7811/1111:46 →dearwilliam:怕玻璃會有煙味220.133.153.7811/1111:46 推akway:我看他要小心人身安全鄰居一定不爽114.42.155.17411/1111:46 推lav1147:爽，罰死他118.163.224.3711/1111:46 推friendly4713:那我也要來蒐證檢舉樓下1.200.194.22711/1111:46 推rumirumi:溫馨114.136.147.14411/1111:46 推pig14283105:爽要吸就在家把窗戶都關好223.136.84.12211/1111:46 →dearwilliam:菸220.133.153.7811/1111:46 推earnformoney:a0913在說啥==現在沒有判例了好嗎117.56.73.1511/1111:46 →lav1147:這種給別人抽二手菸的真的很討厭118.163.224.3711/1111:46 →bill403777:爽42.73.230.17811/1111:46 →paiopapa:划得來呀這樣社區內就沒人敢在他家附近210.59.2.14111/1111:46 →Merkle:愛抽幹嘛去陽台抽怎麼不在自己家裡抽114.25.40.14311/1111:47 →paiopapa:抽菸了又不是只有拿到一萬元這個好處210.59.2.14111/1111:47 →Merkle:房間門窗關起來好好抽阿菸很貴ㄟ114.25.40.14311/1111:47 推duziererder:一萬太少了吧223.139.188.22111/1111:47 推scum5566:爽，要抽就把煙給我吸光111.252.101.10611/1111:47 推Isveia:才判賠一萬...這種的判賠百萬都不為過。

61.58.63.13511/1111:47 推cbr0627:o180.217.115.9411/1111:47 →IHD:怎麼會討厭呢?自助餐就是要這樣玩啊點餐嚕~114.43.155.4911/1111:47 推bischoff804:爽1.167.134.6011/1111:47 →Merkle:關起來閉密環境好好吸個爽阿一堆拉基114.25.40.14311/1111:47 推hw1:法官英明111.71.49.24511/1111:48 →Saza:垃圾自己家裡有人就出來毒害別人?124.8.225.1511/1111:48 →WeGoStyle:才一萬元真是不痛不癢180.217.254.25411/1111:48 →g8429310:讚把鄰居告到哭49.216.122.5811/1111:48 →ctx1000:108年小字第2號民事判決(士林地院)220.135.24.8611/1111:48 →saisai60:讚讚讚讚62.91.10.17511/1111:48 推Lailungsheng:哈哈101.136.193.10011/1111:48 →liao18:菸虫超煩118.168.239.12511/1111:48 推zxc1234529:優質法官223.137.100.14611/1111:48 推hinajian:勵志1.173.76.3011/1111:48 推james80351:酼o好！180.217.224.5211/1111:48 噓aimgel:自己的小孩不能吸到二手煙別人家死不完117.56.51.11711/1111:49 →ifay:爽煙狂去死啦223.140.75.13811/1111:49 →james80351:酼o180.217.224.5211/1111:49 推kit279:一堆在陽台抽,有種怎麼不在家裡抽42.77.189.811/1111:49 推abobstar:二手煙怕給自己小孩吸所以到陽台給別人60.249.227.3411/1111:49 →alex00089:讓人知道他會告人就很那個了42.76.57.22911/1111:49 推eipduolc:我家樓上也有人抽，不過我只拍得到菸36.228.34.19911/1111:49 推dadidi:因為它們梅種抽煙的都是廢物害人害己101.8.226.6611/1111:49 推WeGoYuSheng:菸蟲就是欠罰49.216.29.5211/1111:50 噓tom282f3:菸蟲活該114.136.255.19711/1111:50 →IHD:在路上抽也一堆啊然後說不要酒駕先尬道德?114.43.155.4911/1111:50 →azuel:請菸蟲自己小孩出生的時候天天對孩子吐菸218.161.27.6711/1111:50 →IHD:再喊正義?是抽菸正義還是吸二手煙正義啊?114.43.155.4911/1111:50 →sunlman:這竟然告的成太好了140.112.121.10811/1111:50 噓windowdoor:再抽菸啊以後在路上抽被噴到最好115.82.244.16611/1111:51 →windowdoor:也判賠115.82.244.16611/1111:51 推chocopoodle:菸蟲崩潰223.136.185.18611/1111:51 →soyjay:不是不能抽不要飄出來影響別人啊114.136.188.10811/1111:52 →shadowdio:太爽了我也要去告樓上菸都飄下來操!114.47.178.16811/1111:52 →WeGoYuSheng:還有那種口罩戴一戴，結果「口罩翻49.216.29.5211/1111:52 →WeGoYuSheng:下來點菸」的無恥垃圾也都該罰一罰..49.216.29.5211/1111:52 →WeGoYuSheng:.菸都敢吸了，戴那什麼屁口罩？嫌外49.216.29.5211/1111:52 →WeGoYuSheng:面空氣髒？自己在那吸菸...幹你娘咧.49.216.29.5211/1111:52 →WeGoYuSheng:..49.216.29.5211/1111:52 →colenken:划算啊,未來男子不敢抽了就無價114.42.128.6911/1111:53 推IHD:這個二手煙的正義應該會很很精彩誰的正義正114.43.155.4911/1111:53 推cynthiajul:爽，罰死這些菸蟲台男223.136.80.811/1111:54 推sayme449:爽124.219.107.19611/1111:55 推guitar0225:煙蟲臉皮真厚欠告115.82.191.5111/1111:55 噓DerrickLin:最垃圾的是在人很多夜市抽菸的渣163.16.85.15711/1111:55 推wujunda:垃圾菸蟲101.10.85.5211/1111:56 推Lovemail5566:讚啦223.137.134.10011/1111:56 →s891510:X的我家現在就這樣但抓不到是哪邊飄來的140.119.25.21211/1111:56 推dahlia7357:男的很機掰去噴自己小孩二手菸不會?59.124.115.21111/1111:56 推sempronsp:優質法官223.136.69.4711/1111:56 推CREA:笨死了在浴室抽看誰抓得到1.175.74.7711/1111:56 推fjuting:舒服110.50.177.25111/1111:57 推simon301:爽114.38.68.14511/1111:57 →whccpl:影片呢？101.12.53.4311/1111:57 推guesswhen:垃圾菸狗早點死一死好嗎223.136.28.13511/1111:57 推villagemen:菸粉通常都卻同理心自己想得癌症也223.137.57.13211/1111:57 →protoss666:幸好是在陽台抽如果在家裡抽就看不到61.216.101.16311/1111:57 →villagemen:不管其他人的死活223.137.57.13211/1111:57 推jason1992999:爽邊走邊抽跟在公車站抽的也一起1.160.49.15711/1111:57 推mazznia:讚，愛抽不會關好門自己吸呀，再不然就塑123.194.40.11811/1111:58 →mazznia:膠袋套頭啦。

123.194.40.11811/1111:58 →whccpl:誰叫你不住透天101.12.53.4311/1111:58 推mopigou:不抽菸會死一樣,頭套塑膠袋自己抽自己吸36.231.236.9111/1111:58 →villagemen:但是只賠一萬他一定照抽223.137.57.13211/1111:58 →missingkid:爽啦抽煙的就是欠罰1.175.136.15111/1111:58 推tim9527:煙蟲噁心61.224.71.23711/1111:58 →laroserose:最可惡還有人躲在自家大樓厠所內抽，112.105.219.2511/1111:58 →laroserose:透過空氣循環扇把煙味傳到同棟的住戶112.105.219.2511/1111:59 →laroserose:的厠所，還抓不到兇手112.105.219.2511/1111:59 →guesswhen:幹一堆垃圾陽台抽的馬的幹223.136.28.13511/1111:59 →littlepogi:絕對划算因為難得真的有罰的220.135.138.8311/1111:59 →IHD:這不是聰明嗎?別人生養別人長照?要動腦?114.43.155.4911/1111:59 推glion:讚這些人都不知道二手菸對嬰幼兒有多可怕220.133.77.23711/1111:59 →littlepogi:抽菸都一堆屁理由自己爽別人去死220.135.138.8311/1112:00 推kevin55676:爽101.11.0.1011/1112:00 推gowang19:菸粉真的很過份都不理會別人感受61.62.78.17911/1112:00 噓b9211173:支持戒菸，但處在自家陽台抽還有哪裡可110.50.140.20411/1112:01 →b9211173:抽？110.50.140.20411/1112:01 推IHD:可怕?不支持自助餐更可怕不是嗎?要尬道德114.43.155.4911/1112:01 推Fice:菸蟲欠告42.72.105.12311/1112:01 推WeGoYuSheng:他們不可能不知道啦，但他們心態就是49.216.29.5211/1112:02 →WeGoYuSheng:干我屁事要等到自己真的一腳踏進棺49.216.29.5211/1112:02 →WeGoYuSheng:材才會怕，反正到頭來就是自私冷血四49.216.29.5211/1112:02 →WeGoYuSheng:個字49.216.29.5211/1112:02 推missingkid:我也來檢舉看看隔壁抽煙的媽的每天1.175.136.15111/1112:03 推green0953:我管他在哪裡抽61.228.90.16311/1112:03 →missingkid:抽1.175.136.15111/1112:03 推chister:讚180.217.102.23311/1112:03 →green0953:重點是菸味在我家61.228.90.16311/1112:03 推ken812025:自己房間門窗關緊自己抽自體循環最多101.10.22.15311/1112:03 推ken812025:自己放空濾機阿101.10.22.15311/1112:03 推IVicole:要抽就氣密窗自己家封緊緊再抽啊1.165.208.6411/1112:04 推Spurious:讚二手菸超沒品111.250.132.18511/1112:05 推ken812025:菸蟲自己抽自己爽自己還加濾嘴別人101.10.22.15311/1112:05 →IHD:在公開抽才有爽度啊不然不是歧視嗎?自助餐:114.43.155.4911/1112:05 推std910866e:爽39.9.199.21111/1112:05 推jason1992999:叫菸鬼不要給人吸二手菸，就每次都1.160.49.15711/1112:05 推rapnose:推！111.253.7.22711/1112:05 →ken812025:還要吸你更毒的二手煙喔101.10.22.15311/1112:05 →jason1992999:在靠北說侵害人權1.160.49.15711/1112:05 →IHD:標準自助餐說的才算齁不然就是歧視114.43.155.4911/1112:05 推webber1210:愛抽煙為什麼不在自己房間臭42.76.77.8211/1112:06 噓b9211173:同意室內及廁所禁止吸菸，室外也不行？110.50.140.20411/1112:06 推roger810605:推180.217.173.7511/1112:06 推lkrichard:坐在陽台玻璃帷幕旁感覺是故意的223.136.151.12911/1112:06 推zxzx309:照這種判決，我家門口應該也不能停車，59.115.112.15011/1112:07 →zxzx309:因為會吸到廢氣59.115.112.15011/1112:07 →joinptt:很自私ㄟ，自家小孩不給吸二手煙，轉給鄰210.69.81.211/1112:07 推ksksks:想知道在廁所抽的要怎麼蒐證60.248.18.15511/1112:07 →joinptt:居孕婦抽，還講得很理所當然210.69.81.211/1112:07 推alibuda2014:打寶可夢團體戰時每次就一定會有人吸36.227.86.18711/1112:07 推Xinz:讚！要抽自己帶塑膠袋密閉起來抽！61.221.67.17011/1112:08 →jason1992999:應該給菸鬼蓋一棟吸菸大樓，要吸自1.160.49.15711/1112:08 →jason1992999:己在裡面吸，別出來害人1.160.49.15711/1112:08 →alibuda2014:真希望這些人能得小細胞肺癌死一死36.227.86.18711/1112:08 推wulu0420:判太輕了吧118.233.16.19911/1112:09 推TousBaby:爽1.160.67.2011/1112:09 推webermist:影響到別人就不行啦菸蟲理由真多1.200.32.7611/1112:09 →IHD:能在外抽才平等不是嗎?支持自助餐不身體力?114.43.155.4911/1112:09 推BQird:煙狗愛抽不會自己家內密閉空間抽喔42.72.98.8011/1112:09 →pigc:自己家人不能吸，鄰居可以27.246.136.19411/1112:10 推Lucienne1001:活該不想害自己小孩就可以害別人小110.28.76.111/1112:10 推new71050:幹你娘台男家人吸不行鄰居就可以喔42.72.153.4511/1112:10 →Lucienne1001:孩？110.28.76.111/1112:10 推pente05loser:臉書還一堆菸蟲嘴沒天理幹你老師110.28.141.14311/1112:11 推a1723521:推101.15.196.9411/1112:11 推jack1218:推114.136.160.9911/1112:11 推piliwu:才一萬元根本好笑111.82.218.11811/1112:11 →jack1218:我和應該要寫入刑法114.136.160.9911/1112:11 推seazure2016:真的該告死那些在社區、室內抽煙的111.82.225.21811/1112:11 推pente05loser:怎麼不去毒自己小孩就好110.28.141.14311/1112:11 →baliallin:這麼愛抽頭上套塑膠袋抽自己吸啦124.219.11.14811/1112:11 →seazure2016:人111.82.225.21811/1112:11 →jack1218:看114.136.160.9911/1112:11 推repast:法官英明223.139.213.12011/1112:12 推HatsuneMiku:自己家人不能燻燻鄰居42.72.47.9511/1112:12 推stu25936:覺得判太輕+1101.12.129.10811/1112:12 推kuorobo14:毒蟲再抽啊39.8.94.4011/1112:13 噓zzro:住鳥籠才會有這種問題110.28.77.17811/1112:13 推la8day:垃圾菸鬼27.52.33.1511/1112:13 推ewing1:讚42.72.127.17811/1112:13 推piperyim:抽煙的都吃屎，有夠討厭的114.136.254.9811/1112:13 噓ti1990:抽煙怎不穿無塵衣在裡面抽101.12.47.14111/1112:14 →kill466:"多次投訴社區管委會仍未改善"就故意的啊203.72.8.3611/1112:14 推acer758219:菸蟲要自殺是你家的事別拖別人下水111.71.215.18711/1112:14 →rebai:燒金紙的準備被告49.216.101.14211/1112:15 推normis722:讚喔49.216.56.3311/1112:15 →p852258:爽60.250.236.4311/1112:15 推vltw5v:讚140.119.102.25011/1112:17 →FuwafuwaCAT:爽死好101.12.62.9111/1112:17 推hachilou:讚106.133.41.2211/1112:17 推ethan30213:爽抽菸垃圾125.230.251.1411/1112:17 推alec0219:抽煙的都抓起表演香煙插肛門42.72.247.17411/1112:18 推herculex:菸狗講不聽，活該42.74.120.18211/1112:18 →jaguars33:如果不是孕婦告得贏嗎124.155.178.9211/1112:19 →herculex:菸捐趕快漲到一支五百42.74.120.18211/1112:20 推NCUking:抽菸的幾乎都是垃圾直接榨油才不浪費42.73.35.8411/1112:20 推usokami:蔡菸文:孕婦沒有台灣價值42.72.122.16811/1112:20 推tokyoto:請問廁所的菸味一定是樓下傳上來的嗎？118.160.126.9011/1112:20 推as80110680:讚，垃圾煙蟲再抽啊223.136.93.8111/1112:20 推iPhoneX:公寓有廁所抽的更缺德還抓不到111.241.167.3911/1112:21 推webberhan:推101.15.140.7611/1112:21 推maschera:爽223.136.210.23611/1112:21 →tokyoto:有沒有可能是橫向或是樓上擴散過來的？118.160.126.9011/1112:21 推boris:垃圾菸蟲哈哈223.139.70.7311/1112:22 →IHD:抽菸自由VS吸二手煙自由要先尬道德嗎?114.43.155.4911/1112:22 噓chenyoung411:超討厭菸味，同事出去抽，然後帶著223.136.81.6711/1112:22 →chenyoung411:菸味回辦公室，臭死了，嘔嘔嘔嘔嘔223.136.81.6711/1112:22 →chenyoung411:嘔223.136.81.6711/1112:22 推mimiLin5566:爽60.250.140.10911/1112:22 推ABA0525:罰太少了巴223.139.223.15511/1112:23 推marunouchi:讚！42.77.149.15311/1112:23 推MoWilliams:吸菸者都垃圾低端42.75.136.2811/1112:23 推rutp6j35566:爽61.70.226.21011/1112:23 推brianhsu:爽111.71.100.13311/1112:23 推Mocambique:ㄏㄠㄕㄨ101.10.0.23711/1112:24 推Oxhorn:有的公寓大樓通風出口也會聞到114.40.61.11411/1112:24 推jamey30938:完全划算啊垃圾抽菸狗42.76.67.6311/1112:25 推befound:抽菸的滾好嗎42.76.61.6211/1112:25 推jennifer4551:爽101.15.146.13611/1112:25 →wirecut:好110.26.67.20811/1112:26 推i4undying:太少了影響到胎兒怎麼辦？60.250.204.17011/1112:26 推Mahasata:爽肥宅我都不敢出門因為油臭不敢損人42.77.97.311/1112:26 推ldeathkiller:舒服42.72.3.24511/1112:27 推no1361:自家子女不能吸到，超屌111.71.107.13411/1112:27 推songyy2003:讚42.75.152.14611/1112:28 推luismars:罰錢其次，能讓G8人收斂行為才是重點36.235.8.10111/1112:28 推Sparkle1205:一堆抽不起煙的在腦怒什麼顆顆101.9.22.25511/1112:28 →peiring:愛抽活該101.15.197.2211/1112:28 推T74:去頂樓抽啦乾，有頂加的再爬到屋頂上啦乾223.140.152.11711/1112:28 →jaseman:已經一堆二手菸危害的報告…還是很多人喜27.246.140.16011/1112:29 →jaseman:歡做損人不利己的事27.246.140.16011/1112:29 →sakamichi:愛抽不會家裡隔一間半坪大密閉空間在裡42.76.73.1111/1112:29 →sakamichi:面抽個過癮，像在養茶壺一樣，要吸自己42.76.73.1111/1112:29 推JIWP:爽223.140.135.19111/1112:30 →sakamichi:吸，別害別人42.76.73.1111/1112:30 推QB5566:這些人就想抽隨時抽完全不管旁邊有人114.47.117.6911/1112:30 推iamhemry:抽菸就是自私223.140.37.9611/1112:31 推popgsct:溫馨垃圾菸蟲被罰就是爽118.171.122.20211/1112:31 推aalleexx:才一萬媽的111.71.54.7311/1112:31 →bilibo:煙蟲就是欠罵110.26.194.20911/1112:32 推g9122xj:划算，不然雞掰人根本不會收斂101.12.205.8511/1112:32 推fire124:竟然告的成，台灣又往前一大步了42.72.92.17911/1112:32 推a28200266:好爽223.137.235.19111/1112:32 →IHD:支持自助餐就要身體力行啊不吸二手菸?支持?114.43.155.4911/1112:32 推lnmp:讚39.9.65.23711/1112:33 推nsaids:不會自己頭上套塑膠袋抽到爽118.170.69.17111/1112:33 推Coslate:抽煙的垃圾42.73.184.24511/1112:33 推tetsu0401:爽27.52.132.19811/1112:33 推teikoting:英明判決118.171.112.12411/1112:33 推koyuri:公司大樓特別隔了一間吸煙室,結果都沒人去59.124.71.24111/1112:33 推satonoo:菸蟲果然一堆垃圾有夠自私61.220.35.8611/1112:33 推homestay:最垃圾的煙蟲好像不上PTT的42.73.202.2911/1112:34 推ez0980:菸粉水準61.70.168.21111/1112:34 推CCNK:叫政府不要賣嘛又賣又罰根本釣魚有沒有違220.138.45.13311/1112:34 →koyuri:都跑去一樓中庭抽,連吸煙的都不想吸2手煙59.124.71.24111/1112:34 推KGB13:推106.1.102.4411/1112:34 →CCNK:憲啊220.138.45.13311/1112:34 推illegalmad:英明42.73.234.23111/1112:35 推southernwood:告得好111.71.67.5711/1112:35 推HermesKing:讚123.193.253.14111/1112:35 推s9209122222:爽218.173.58.8311/1112:35 推bbc0217:菸粉崩潰61.223.104.23211/1112:36 推minipc:抽煙者取消健保資格啦幹27.52.195.8411/1112:36 推photoshark:帥，告爆菸粉101.11.16.23411/1112:37 推Jsayta:讚讚讚223.136.66.6711/1112:37 噓keepwild:垃圾菸鬼，怎麼不去吃大便1.200.196.911/1112:38 推chaobii:活該，自私的東西就是要給他教訓27.52.39.22511/1112:38 推nimby:自己有三個小孩不能在家抽，所以別人小孩死114.43.64.6611/1112:38 →nimby:好114.43.64.6611/1112:38 推iverson313:我的在陽台抽，爽114.32.164.25211/1112:38 推YummyCurry:水223.137.132.6111/1112:39 推s860134:水27.52.108.1711/1112:39 推missin:跟行政罰的金額差不多啊QQ1.200.46.14911/1112:40 推CTUST:這種垃圾拼命增生114.136.152.2411/1112:40 推silencemars:抽煙就認份一點吧111.83.196.10211/1112:41 推marble:罰太少114.34.40.3811/1112:43 推farmoos:這種抽煙的人很多39.10.172.10311/1112:43 →jackwula9211:爽，菸蟲該死223.137.221.10311/1112:43 推alonso888:PUSH!114.43.166.22211/1112:43 →abccat0520:幹抽屁抽喔，不抽菸是會死嗎150.66.78.16411/1112:44 →opmikoto:靠我也想檢舉了125.227.151.12111/1112:44 推martinshih:讚讚讚27.247.62.1711/1112:44 推a8077616530:吸菸都垃圾啊111.71.59.13911/1112:44 →abccat0520:為什麼別人要忍受你的垃圾二手菸150.66.78.16411/1112:44 推iuexeyz:水哦42.74.250.1811/1112:44 推wison4451:爽42.72.143.9511/1112:45 推Raikkonen01:幹在陽台吸煙真的超可惡27.246.167.16611/1112:45 推Anth:推69.143.223.11011/1112:45 推smooth2mj3:推60.250.203.21711/1112:45 噓s955055:什麼垃圾人啊，不讓自己子女吸二手菸，27.247.232.10311/1112:45 →s955055:倒可以讓別人胎兒吸27.247.232.10311/1112:45 推nakinight:罰十萬差不多203.81.181.7811/1112:45 推kixer2005:太輕應該立法唯一死刑1.200.54.18611/1112:46 推damingli90:一般人檢舉沒用吧是因為孕婦才有用1.161.115.10211/1112:46 →damingli90:而且檢舉完後知道是誰檢舉的後面才1.161.115.10211/1112:46 推Nano:吸煙都他媽是狗雜碎223.136.144.1111/1112:46 →damingli90:好玩有的人是不會吞下這口氣的喔自1.161.115.10211/1112:46 →damingli90:己要注意1.161.115.10211/1112:47 推nanja750113:song39.11.230.8911/1112:47 推keyman2:小菸粉大菸粉生7761.231.154.4811/1112:47 推ikeep:連煙都拍的出來可見有多濃123.193.209.5011/1112:47 推shawncarter:推抽煙沒關係但是真的不要讓別人吸36.226.29.3511/1112:49 →shawncarter:到二手菸36.226.29.3511/1112:49 推ff7sephiroth:太棒了，今年就為了隔壁抽煙都會開42.73.191.21911/1112:50 →ff7sephiroth:窗搬家，每次下班都還要吸他二手煙42.73.191.21911/1112:50 推kenphin0729:菸蟲欠罰，但判太低101.137.81.18211/1112:50 推pheadra:爽125.227.89.7711/1112:50 推Leeabel:該罰223.136.253.21211/1112:51 噓ray157023:噓，賠太少27.52.201.18011/1112:51 推astroflyer:這個竟然能告得成？？180.217.141.7811/1112:51 推et3003:溫馨!!爽啦，在陽台抽菸的都不得好死113.196.180.13811/1112:52 →astroflyer:之前看其他的案例都告不到只能通過管180.217.141.7811/1112:52 推b436412:爽42.73.149.14711/1112:52 →astroflyer:委會180.217.141.7811/1112:52 推nerdmode:才罰一萬而已==140.120.9.8211/1112:53 推shioulanyu:希望檢舉達人找找這些愛抽煙的人101.136.25.14811/1112:53 推scccc:太讚了，原來能告的成，害我都拿循環扇吹回60.251.194.10611/1112:55 推nectared:爽163.43.104.3511/1112:55 →scccc:去60.251.194.10611/1112:55 推lmf770410:讚111.82.150.2011/1112:55 推Noxus:這麼喜歡抽煙為啥不關在家裡獨享？111.241.215.11111/1112:55 推g3sg1:幹我大概也該跟人合作去修理那垃圾鄰居了111.249.30.2811/1112:56 推moonshock:讚菸蟲他媽的去死223.136.226.17811/1112:56 推ringohejia:垃圾菸蟲1.173.57.9511/1112:56 推ssmm5566:備註讓人無言，這種就是要給教訓180.217.181.11011/1112:56 推keddy20c:在陽台抽菸、邊騎摩托車邊抽菸、在路上125.227.234.11111/1112:56 →keddy20c:抽菸的人都很討人厭，孕婦聞到煙味整個125.227.234.11111/1112:56 →keddy20c:快崩潰125.227.234.11111/1112:57 噓js52666:是沒吸菸室跟你用膩36.235.131.11211/1112:57 →js52666:給你用36.235.131.11211/1112:57 噓OGC218:幹～樓下的菸味都飄上來101.12.13.9111/1112:57 推cyuan0301:爽223.138.2.10811/1112:58 推madwindfeng:讚175.96.81.4111/1112:59 推YingJiou5566:嗯不錯24.5.6.1111/1112:59 推Sechss:菸蟲吃屎114.136.214.1311/1112:59 推diablohinet:抽菸給別人聞的都去死一死27.52.65.25011/1113:00 推attpp:當煙草吃下去就算了180.204.0.16411/1113:00 →akissiva:一包菸$1000就不會這麼多增加健康成本的36.233.11.20811/1113:01 推aqsss:喜歡抽菸幹嘛不找密閉空間一手二手不浪費140.112.125.20611/1113:01 →akissiva:事36.233.11.20811/1113:01 →bearhwa:才一萬給菸蟲賺到了122.100.126.19411/1113:03 推Flame705:哈哈可撥煙蟲最好再罰多一點101.137.15.2311/1113:03 推mayii1020:抽煙廢物想死自己死不要出來害人60.250.199.10911/1113:04 推smart8122:讚36.226.164.17611/1113:05 推Philethan:爽啦140.112.4.19211/1113:06 推aasaasaas947:台灣常態，慘1.200.219.24711/1113:07 推qaz223gy:起碼10萬吧？42.74.163.15911/1113:07 推bluelikeme:好爽一萬給他繼續抽嘻嘻101.14.208.19411/1113:07 推kichitai:讚111.83.34.11511/1113:07 推cgabear:推，親身體會這種人讓人不堪其擾163.20.242.11411/1113:07 噓kkb512sk:菸就是毒品還是容易致癌的毒品223.140.254.16211/1113:07 →kichitai:抽煙的都該死啦111.83.34.11511/1113:07 →kkb512sk:持有跟販賣應該通通抓去槍斃223.140.254.16211/1113:08 推ernova831:煙蟲無恥36.224.97.311/1113:08 推G41:爽抽煙的都是xx42.76.28.9311/1113:09 推veryGY:半夜怎麼錄影真想教訓退休老人220.135.181.17211/1113:10 推lin0579:顯然知道二手菸對人體的危害才到陽台抽140.113.136.21911/1113:11 →bingreen:至少個十萬才會有感吧182.234.81.3811/1113:11 推GooglePixel:在廚房開抽油煙機抽好了27.52.38.23511/1113:12 推nonjolno00:爽啦抽煙嘔嘔嘔嘔嘔101.9.141.1611/1113:13 推s0450336:抽煙不就大家一起死的概念42.72.126.11011/1113:13 推ji394tb:煙味真的很臭119.31.189.211/1113:13 噓gary82gary:政府的錯啊，還不如賣低濃度的毒品，1.200.223.18911/1113:15 →gary82gary:至少自己吃還不會影響到人1.200.223.18911/1113:15 推dokinkon:才一萬也太少114.32.29.1011/1113:15 推andyssfresh:推應該正面表列能吸煙的地點101.11.32.20011/1113:17 推bon362:一萬對癮君子來說是小錢42.72.232.22611/1113:18 →ebeta:抽煙仔都去死好嗎？27.246.99.24211/1113:19 推gguntank:才1萬哦10萬都嫌少223.138.107.25311/1113:20 推wolfofschool:判太少了吧180.217.76.3211/1113:20 推zo3chen:真的，愛抽煙就在自己小房間裡面裡面抽不36.11.225.22711/1113:20 →zo3chen:要出來害人36.11.225.22711/1113:20 推fakeimage:這種只保護自己家人薰別人孩子的最爛114.45.62.7511/1113:20 推Rodstrupe:時間成本加胎兒健康隱憂原告其實還是110.28.41.811/1113:20 →Rodstrupe:輸…110.28.41.811/1113:20 推demitri:這真的活該了104.32.182.18011/1113:21 →demitri:都投訴多次這的活該104.32.182.18011/1113:21 推vi000246:才一萬以後照樣抽60.251.47.19711/1113:22 推tikitaka:至少要10萬42.73.8.7511/1113:22 推laytomall:罰起來39.13.67.20211/1113:22 推charlieliu:送223.136.3.14411/1113:23 推e1q3z9c7:沒辦法完全禁菸好歹開放電子菸和加熱菸58.114.7.16311/1113:23 →e1q3z9c7:不然這種根本告不完58.114.7.16311/1113:23 推spring12215:爽啦不過賠太少了，而且家裡有三個101.15.218.8011/1113:24 →spring12215:未滿七歲的孩子所以跑到陽台吸真的101.15.218.8011/1113:24 推darkhells:爽36.229.94.19411/1113:24 →spring12215:是別人家的孩子死不完的概念欸.....101.15.218.8011/1113:24 推ppc:爽27.246.198.15611/1113:24 推ffreya:一萬真是太少了220.129.183.611/1113:25 推chocopie:賠得好42.72.234.15911/1113:25 推mouse07:繼續抽就繼續告118.163.12.15111/1113:25 推scedbo412:菸捐啥時要漲100倍阿36.237.149.16811/1113:26 →windalso:別人小孩死不完？111.250.29.2011/1113:26 推corlos:推220.228.56.1811/1113:27 推rayray123:垃圾別人的妻兒死不完39.11.167.3511/1113:28 噓DuGoGo:抽煙就是自私的人閃遠點不會嗎220.141.128.20411/1113:28 推Lydia66:自己有三個小孩所以不在屋內抽菸蒸蚌180.177.113.23811/1113:28 →rayray123:套個塑膠袋自己吸好吸滿39.11.167.3511/1113:29 推k5a:抽菸應該鞭刑吧台灣真的對這太縱容了42.75.189.14511/1113:29 推jeff52:抽煙的人想死就自己死一死就好，不要害別36.239.71.111/1113:30 →jeff52:人得肺癌！36.239.71.111/1113:30 →jeff52:個人認為抽煙的人的醫療費健保應該一率不36.239.71.111/1113:30 →jeff52:予給付36.239.71.111/1113:30 推minipig0102:爽223.136.7.19911/1113:31 →gotohikaru:不少國家大樓公寓在住家也不能抽了175.182.10.19211/1113:31 推jeff52:抽煙或二手菸會讓胎兒過敏機率增加，要是36.239.71.111/1113:32 →jeff52:小孩以後真的有過敏，一定要把那個抽煙的36.239.71.111/1113:32 →jeff52:傢伙告到破產！36.239.71.111/1113:32 推dobe:不想讓自己小孩抽二手菸所以到外面讓別人抽39.12.161.4111/1113:32 →dobe:二手菸好偉大喔39.12.161.4111/1113:32 推FragileLin:有夠爽42.73.126.22611/1113:32 推cookiecloud:爽啦抽菸的死好XDDDDD111.82.33.18911/1113:33 推loveyanzi03:才一萬太少了吧101.12.44.19211/1113:34 推sean5236921:賠他媽百萬咧真會講^_^66.42.32.20511/1113:34 推wryyyyyyyy:爽27.246.133.7811/1113:34 →laechan:菸害防治法讀熟一點42.76.210.19011/1113:35 →rayven:1萬元不就菸害防制法的上限嗎89.187.161.19611/1113:36 推evaal:抽煙好啊！要鼓勵他多多抽，三倍抽，棒！171.36.179.13611/1113:36 推Tawara:靠這煙霧這麼大喔XD118.163.96.12711/1113:37 推raysamjett:讚！愛抽菸就門窗緊閉自己吸，別害人106.107.247.18211/1113:37 →raysamjett:希望法律能提高罰則，保險遇有吸菸者106.107.247.18211/1113:38 →raysamjett:皆不賠106.107.247.18211/1113:38 推offdensen:爽啦垃圾抽菸狗49.216.101.14711/1113:39 推chuangs:抽煙真的沒水準111.71.18.17211/1113:39 噓cursedsoul:重點又不是錢，是不要他再抽煙180.204.82.13611/1113:42 推csmith:新北市大樓警衛直接在大樓非吸菸區吸菸勒111.249.138.3211/1113:43 推aikoDisk:抽煙的把別人當空氣濾清機害人划算嗎？110.50.178.1211/1113:45 →fg008kimo:判得非常好118.163.125.18711/1113:46 推ALENDA:幹得好，以後有案例可參照了76.105.149.811/1113:46 推snas:超討厭這種的，一天每隔三小時抽一次，連窗70.112.54.6611/1113:47 →snas:戶都不能開，開車就不知道半夜什麼時候菸飄70.112.54.6611/1113:47 →snas:進來70.112.54.6611/1113:47 推Windcws9Z:59.127.190.3611/1113:47 →snas:開窗*70.112.54.6611/1113:47 推benny3579:罰死那些煙槍舒服42.73.245.15211/1113:48 推jejeje:讚讚讚180.217.102.24411/1113:48 推happypg:某樓說到口罩幹咧49.217.233.4411/1113:48 →happypg:十個騎二行程的有九個戴口罩49.217.233.4411/1113:49 推happypg:還在那邊補助換車補三小直接禁二行程好49.217.233.4411/1113:50 推esonda:還好我戒了不然在台灣一堆人看不順眼就先101.12.61.15411/1113:53 →esonda:禁而不是理性的想配套101.12.61.15411/1113:54 推dododoremi:划算還有上法庭的時間114.136.254.21011/1113:54 推hugh4132000:在家裡自己吸啦87114.35.19.111/1113:55 推YuenYang5566:活該，爽啦廢物廢物菸蟲223.139.167.15011/1113:55 →a0226958831:煙蟲崩潰118.163.39.8711/1113:55 推Hirano:抽菸的不得好死下地獄42.77.215.12611/1113:57 推aaronpwyu:一萬太少了支持114.170.166.2511/1113:57 →kangbow:台灣人永遠只會解決人不會解決問題~118.170.55.11211/1113:58 推lozupomelo:讚42.74.186.1911/1113:58 推whface:這些吸菸虫自己死就好，不要連累他人223.139.167.20411/1113:58 →kangbow:健康捐的錢也全部都丟別人口袋裡了118.170.55.11211/1113:59 推cbstgb:爽49.219.172.17511/1113:59 推HarrisLind:爽啦114.136.238.13511/1114:00 推chiz2:抽煙的十個有九個是沒懶趴只能靠煙的孬種1.171.156.15011/1114:00 推a110002211:爽49.215.227.5411/1114:01 推emptydia:讚讚111.254.68.6811/1114:01 噓atana:在自己家抽也有問題？換個律師吧223.139.238.7911/1114:02 →prkfcpr:爽180.217.95.14611/1114:02 推CappuCat:呵呵118.166.65.3011/1114:03 →prkfcpr:噓的估計都沒在看內文180.217.95.14611/1114:03 推ethan0419:推111.184.73.8011/1114:06 推fly40314:爽27.246.12.15111/1114:09 噓CY40:該判個十萬不為過223.138.38.15411/1114:09 推lionling:科科36.226.68.1611/1114:10 推ray10133:讚1.171.192.3511/1114:12 推rugia813:支持全面撲殺菸蟲61.220.112.22411/1114:14 推sleepsnow:自己小孩不能吸二手菸，別人就可以??111.83.201.16311/1114:14 推gogoyamaha:真的爽60.250.144.18011/1114:14 噓TobyH4cker:一堆老人看不懂內文27.246.69.13911/1114:15 推huabandd:不是划算問題是爽度101.137.175.18011/1114:15 推Asucks:爽59.115.86.19911/1114:16 推anaydh:讚39.12.37.1611/1114:16 推visa829:讚111.83.254.17411/1114:17 噓bumloveme:那麼愛抽怎麼不在家裡房間關門抽啊？114.136.114.3511/1114:17 推jesuscries:一萬有點少吧42.72.214.18511/1114:19 推jameshuangg:再說一次抽煙就是噁心自私，不服來辯42.73.172.6711/1114:19 推ccdilnc:如果是靠這賺錢就不划算101.137.225.19811/1114:20 推deadogy:幹得好，抽煙垃圾101.15.162.13611/1114:23 推juyac11:最恨邊走路邊抽菸一路都是煙味垃圾人118.166.128.311/1114:24 推szuwei0311:爽42.74.253.9211/1114:26 →shwkz:重點是這些人臉皮厚到被討厭也不管繼續抽150.117.204.1211/1114:26 推flowersuger:爽36.235.22.15611/1114:29 推datboi:菸應該列為毒品吸的廢物抓去關223.141.92.16211/1114:29 推tmpss93103:媽的垃圾菸鬼自己在房間吸好吸滿啦42.75.161.21511/1114:30 推Ycosmos:爽二手菸臭死126.204.196.3311/1114:31 推FlyinwindX:教訓一下自私鬼我覺得是蠻棒的27.247.199.9611/1114:34 推ltsart0515:讚1.164.243.3511/1114:35 推usoko:才一萬得癌症法官要幫忙出醫藥費嗎?122.147.214.18611/1114:36 →usoko:好歹也要加註不得再製造二手菸吧122.147.214.18611/1114:37 推justiceyes:菸蟲活該114.36.11.19911/1114:38 推JamesChan51:讚，抽菸的可以關在自己家慢慢吸，聞39.8.169.16111/1114:41 →JamesChan51:到就討厭39.8.169.16111/1114:41 推NYQQ:太好了101.15.196.711/1114:45 推bigteddy:爽101.15.192.9511/1114:47 推Brucetsai541:菸蟲吃屎114.44.137.23811/1114:48 推mra2284:法官英明27.247.41.11511/1114:49 推Charmeur:推118.167.129.5411/1114:50 推kzlivetune:爽菸蟲都吃屎42.76.228.17711/1114:54 推jbmm:自家有小孩所以不在家裏抽，在陽台薰隔壁孕180.217.89.14711/1114:56 →jbmm:婦=_=180.217.89.14711/1114:56 推gala1217:吸菸可，但呼二手菸給別人吸真的垃圾。

101.136.46.16111/1114:58 →gala1217:鄰居也是十一二點都會在車庫吸菸，菸味101.136.46.16111/1114:59 →gala1217:飄散晚上都不敢把衣物晾在外頭，認真認101.136.46.16111/1114:59 →gala1217:為吸菸而得肺癌的人真的活該且浪費健保101.136.46.16111/1114:59 噓relio:抽菸的都去死49.215.146.5611/1114:59 推qoo4628802:抽煙真的都低b兒又臭42.73.164.23411/1114:59 推qsef5:爽，抽煙的都廢物223.137.98.2611/1115:00 推gala1217:希望健康捐再繼續漲漲漲漲漲漲漲101.136.46.16111/1115:02 推roystorm:爽，煙鬼全都死一死120.105.145.19111/1115:02 推Totoro0802:爽42.75.190.6111/1115:03 →piece1:可上訴還好啦!!36.231.134.14311/1115:03 →gala1217:從健保中除名！吸菸是自願自殺啊啊啊101.136.46.16111/1115:04 推joe2233344:抽煙真的他媽死垃圾欸42.72.77.19811/1115:05 推XDXDXDID:抽屁抽菸蟲怎不去吃屎125.230.218.6811/1115:08 →yutinbabe:煙鬼活該39.12.103.20611/1115:09 推piggymelon:支持吸菸者都戴魚缸吸，熏死自己39.10.42.16311/1115:13 推zzzyoyoyo:讚，最討厭吸煙的人了223.140.197.13911/1115:13 →yantingtw:我家鄰居躲浴室抽，很難舉證，e04114.34.30.20411/1115:14 推wenhuanorman:讚，那種邊走邊抽的更應該如此210.71.78.24411/1115:17 噓dustmoon:抽煙給人聞的都垃圾49.215.181.1211/1115:20 推eDrifter:這可以220.141.13.11211/1115:20 推Kreen:推，讚，明智的法官～223.141.41.7311/1115:22 推loking:為什麼不死刑114.136.25.20411/1115:24 推brian060587:垃圾菸蟲死好223.136.197.1311/1115:27 推garlicbap:爽啦！吸菸害人害己59.127.62.10711/1115:31 推james791013:最垃圾的是在浴室抽42.76.10.2811/1115:33 推Michaelpipen:垃圾人114.37.25.7011/1115:34 推PennyFinn:住大樓一天到晚都有旁邊飄來的煙味啦111.82.241.6511/1115:36 推aigle:有本事就不要吐出來180.217.143.20211/1115:38 推cabybara9120:垃圾菸蟲101.11.11.6311/1115:49 推cerwvk:萬元有夠便宜，上法院打官司，擺明叫你別223.140.21.6711/1115:50 →cerwvk:煩法院，不是嗎？223.140.21.6711/1115:50 →notneme159:推個42.76.75.1111/1115:50 →ISbn94:菸害防治法根本笑話法36.232.25.12711/1115:51 →cerwvk:可教化，重罰，這擺明你確定要上法院求正223.140.21.6711/1115:52 →cerwvk:義？還是懲罰被害人？223.140.21.6711/1115:52 推maxmars:開心爽175.192.226.24611/1115:53 推LeMirage2000:爽啦42.77.38.8211/1115:57 推horseinwine:爽180.217.243.14711/1116:05 推evelyn055:太好了總算正義得以伸張223.136.45.4511/1116:05 →linzero:社區大樓類型的，廁所偷抽比較難被抓到114.44.78.19311/1116:09 推ntustjc:每次晚上周圍就有鄰居不定時抽煙找不到223.136.96.20611/1116:12 →ntustjc:來源真的超幹223.136.96.20611/1116:12 推aa1052026:若我住大樓被檢舉，絕對在廁所狂點菸洩61.57.71.2011/1116:13 →aa1052026:憤61.57.71.2011/1116:13 推watwmark:抽菸的垃圾就是討人厭1.161.248.2911/1116:15 噓Smily79:政府應該要推行哪些地方可以抽菸而不是110.26.94.7811/1116:15 →Smily79:推哪些地方禁菸110.26.94.7811/1116:15 推piolet:在自己家裡面抽毒自己人就好125.230.195.21911/1116:16 推afking:太少49.217.83.4311/1116:19 推iphone12:政府應該推行全國禁菸180.204.244.12811/1116:19 噓kenichisun:被告一定沒有黨證，不然超抽也沒關係182.232.198.2211/1116:22 推hdw:爽!!!那麼臭的東西也在抽60.251.244.9411/1116:23 推a35715987:太少垃圾菸蟲223.137.64.3211/1116:26 推BigDK:每天都快被吸菸的鄰居搞瘋，真他媽的119.77.149.23011/1116:27 推ndtoseooqd:希望騎樓比照辦理223.136.109.24011/1116:33 推sss6515366:抽菸就是垃圾要死死自己還害別人114.39.111.611/1116:33 推windclock:可以聞一次告一次嗎？39.9.4.17411/1116:38 推chidori728:爽220.132.241.1611/1116:40 噓s9300519:這好笑了，給別人吸二手煙卻不給家人吸1.171.123.18111/1116:45 推davidbright:又一成功案例囉1.168.53.14911/1116:49 推kiplove114:爽61.220.183.11811/1116:52 推qwejoezxc33:欸妳過來插一下賺223.137.217.6611/1116:57 推je789520:抽三小煙死煙蟲111.248.93.24011/1116:59 →THEKYLE:抽菸的肺癌死一死啦～雞掰～49.216.62.5411/1117:00 推iamtc769:舒服101.9.198.17511/1117:06 推joe61008:舒服＝＝42.75.97.21011/1117:07 推hanamini:推101.14.168.9111/1117:09 推chen09:還可上訴223.137.197.21411/1117:09 推luminodot:抽煙垃圾都不在自己家跟車上抽到外面203.69.34.20511/1117:09 →luminodot:去害人203.69.34.20511/1117:09 推pcl11051214:判賠了才一萬真的太少，難怪大家還是114.136.142.4711/1117:12 →pcl11051214:繼續抽114.136.142.4711/1117:13 推ringohare:爽49.216.56.19711/1117:18 推mystage:我覺得至少要賠五萬吧，不然律師費都不夠1.161.48.1811/1117:21 推crazy1009:菸蟲欠吉活該死好61.228.201.14011/1117:34 推stlevi811101:爽菸蟲==垃圾140.113.62.22011/1117:37 →stlevi811101:試問台灣有多少菸癮者會亂丟菸蒂??140.113.62.22011/1117:38 →stlevi811101:100%140.113.62.22011/1117:38 推soranosakana:樓下一堆工人抽菸還會上空躺在騎樓101.15.146.22911/1117:39 →soranosakana:真的很沒水準101.15.146.22911/1117:39 推orzkk88:台男素質自己小孩不能吸給別人吸140.114.135.1811/1117:41 推sour801808:沒水準下地獄223.136.180.4811/1117:41 推reikibarara:我也好想樓下101.136.235.20411/1118:03 →reikibarara:告101.136.235.20411/1118:03 推lecognac:爽111.71.218.811/1118:07 →qmaper:自己家不抽去陽台毒鄰居59.126.246.9311/1118:09 推jansan:爽1.161.5.15211/1118:20 推yumanatu:真可惜，才賠1萬，應該賠100萬61.224.47.23011/1118:28 推fruitlu:推推42.73.162.21111/1118:40 推xsexyx:幹得好1.200.206.18211/1118:55 推bightv19018:讚，這應該漲價101.13.161.22911/1119:02 推abcd1111:推49.217.163.2911/1119:03 →bightv19018:菸蟲針對很噁，吸合法毒品毒害他人101.13.161.22911/1119:03 推Fangshiuan:吸菸的都吃屎好嗎+136.238.204.3911/1119:09 推stw0975:爽218.173.135.4111/1119:20 →weibolin:邊騎車邊抽菸的也很可惡停紅燈被迫一1.175.123.22311/1119:26 →weibolin:起吸騎在後面也是1.175.123.22311/1119:26 推ko7811520:賠好少119.15.228.6411/1120:18 推peanut910013:前幾天才遇過愛抽給別人聞又無限自114.136.162.2811/1120:19 →peanut910013:我膨脹的垃圾114.136.162.2811/1120:19 推jasonvt:讚223.138.217.4511/1120:29 →doggycxj:對不起我以後不會在陽台抽菸了改躲在122.116.79.16111/1120:43 →doggycxj:棉被裡抽122.116.79.16111/1120:43 →dudee:不想害自己未成年小孩值得教化...不是那種223.138.160.23711/1121:12 →dudee:案件喔？223.138.160.23711/1121:12 →dudee:很多垃圾菸蟲開車邊開窗抽煙，既然喜歡吸菸223.138.160.23711/1121:13 →dudee:何必開窗？223.138.160.23711/1121:13 →CozyLife:垃圾菸狗全部死一死39.12.45.3811/1121:53 推mikasakai:幹拎喇！抽煙影響到別人的都去死223.136.131.14311/1121:55 推YUYENHU:為什麼吸菸不能穿像海賊王裡面天龍人的頭101.15.161.9711/1122:20 →YUYENHU:罩吸菸？101.15.161.9711/1122:20 →YUYENHU:自體循環蠻好的呀！101.15.161.9711/1122:20 推gin10791:你要抽你要先講啊垃圾菸粉118.161.48.3311/1122:50 推williamhyw:抽菸的人什麼時候死光光101.9.161.10011/1123:13 推Syoshinsya:菸粉去死啦110.50.138.15511/1123:41 推troubledanny:煙蟲超垃圾。

抽毒給別人吸101.12.224.2411/1123:55 推crazwade:爽111.71.213.17711/1200:20 推weselyong:便宜了111.241.165.7011/1200:28 推mswinnie:讚！罰死他！1.161.205.24011/1200:39 →howard878:爽1.163.40.11911/1200:50 推yehmei0102:菸蟲吃屎220.136.51.13011/1204:18 推laiex22:抽菸吃屎吧110.26.75.9811/1207:19 推marco79811:就說台灣的菸還太便宜了吧101.15.140.3111/1207:42 推mhliu8:去頂樓抽很難嗎？42.72.32.18111/1208:10 推utf84067:爽支持這位法官61.224.136.3011/1208:20 推m4tl6:讚101.136.158.13811/1212:25 →horb:吸煙不敢給家人吸到都走到別人門口給別人42.73.31.23511/1222:12 →horb:吸很討厭42.73.31.23511/1222:12 推wenyii:抽菸94垃圾，自己想死還要殘害別人39.8.226.4111/1222:51 分享給朋友 更多medi588文章 相同討論串 返回Gossiping看板 近期熱門文章 786 [新聞]快訊/指揮中心修訂「新冠肺炎」定義:快篩 1496 05/0514:19 Gossiping 更多jason486文章 711 [新聞]台灣疫情將成無政府狀態？柯文哲：有政府 1387 05/0511:35 Gossiping 更多Wojnarowski文章 884 [新聞]快訊／國民黨團爆：快篩試劑進口商竟是 1478 05/0411:11 Gossiping 更多zoeapezoo文章 971 [爆卦]羅氏快篩的經銷商牛耳是不是很厲害？ 1342 05/0413:19 Gossiping 更多cherish18文章 681 [新聞]「叫大家別直接衝急診，自己卻衝了！」他 1335 05/0411:43 Gossiping 更多venson文章 477 [新聞]藍委緊咬高登環球體質差　陳時中動怒：?1 1465 05/0512:23 Gossiping 更多cherish18文章 410 [新聞]高登老闆背景曝光金主代表發聲:決定棄標 1493 05/0423:10 Gossiping 更多DamnDre文章 734 [問卦]快篩是不是水超深呀？ 1136 05/0419:21 Gossiping 更多vickyshan文章 716 Re:[爆卦]羅氏快篩的經銷商牛耳是不是很厲害？ 1033 05/0417:56 Gossiping 更多cherish18文章 500 [爆卦]快篩試劑獨厚綠友友陳時中踹共 993 05/0511:26 Gossiping 更多ga200677509文章 Gossiping熱門文章 786 [新聞]快訊/指揮中心修訂「新冠肺炎」定義:快篩 1496 05/0514:19 Gossiping 更多jason486文章 711 [新聞]台灣疫情將成無政府狀態？柯文哲：有政府 1387 05/0511:35 Gossiping 更多Wojnarowski文章 884 [新聞]快訊／國民黨團爆：快篩試劑進口商竟是 1478 05/0411:11 Gossiping 更多zoeapezoo文章 971 [爆卦]羅氏快篩的經銷商牛耳是不是很厲害？ 1342 05/0413:19 Gossiping 更多cherish18文章 681 [新聞]「叫大家別直接衝急診，自己卻衝了！」他 1335 05/0411:43 Gossiping 更多venson文章 477 [新聞]藍委緊咬高登環球體質差　陳時中動怒：?1 1465 05/0512:23 Gossiping 更多cherish18文章 410 [新聞]高登老闆背景曝光金主代表發聲:決定棄標 1493 05/0423:10 Gossiping 更多DamnDre文章 734 [問卦]快篩是不是水超深呀？ 1136 05/0419:21 Gossiping 更多vickyshan文章 716 Re:[爆卦]羅氏快篩的經銷商牛耳是不是很厲害？ 1033 05/0417:56 Gossiping 更多cherish18文章 500 [爆卦]快篩試劑獨厚綠友友陳時中踹共 993 05/0511:26 Gossiping 更多ga200677509文章

請為這篇文章評分？

延伸文章資訊